July 3, 2023
DSBC Associate Morgan Long explains how to navigate the unique relationship with the insured during the course of a subrogation claim.
June 20, 2023
Florida allows subrogation recovery for damage due to the spread of fire from a neighboring property. Discover three strategies that can be employed when attempting to develop a theory of liability.
June 5, 2023
As a professional cake artist and baker turned attorney, I like to think of a successful subrogation claim as a perfectly constructed recipe. Some may think that overlooking the smallest detail is immaterial. However, if you forget a teaspoon of baking powder in your beautiful pound cake, the consistency will become heavy, grainy and unappealing. Claims management is no different, and one small miss may be no less detrimental than that missing baking powder.
Properly constructing a subrogation claim is no different than baking that perfectly fluffy and flavorful cake. Just like managing a claim, I like to gather all of my ingredients before I begin measuring and mixing. Similarly, when a claim is first reported, it is crucial to gather all necessary information relating to what happened before, during, and after the loss. You will want to collect every single piece of evidence and facts surrounding the loss. Without doing so, you will likely forget one crucial ingredient necessary to your recipe.
Let’s imagine we’re making a carrot cake. There are so many possibilities of what could be included – do you want raisins or nuts in your carrot cake? Maybe you also want to add some pineapple…I’m just saying, don’t knock it until you try it. Like carrot cake, there are several potential ingredients, or parties that may be to blame for the loss. This is why it is so important to gather every fact and get your insured or client on the phone. In many instances of vehicle fires, it is assumed there is a manufacturing defect; however, without first gathering all of the facts, you may miss that the insured recently had an oil change or repair done by a third-party company. This information will not only be helpful in knowing who to put on notice for any examinations, but also to provide your expert with that golden nugget of information that may lead them to a strong finding and opinion.
In addition to gathering all the facts, you want to ensure that all necessary documents are collected as soon as possible to prevent them from being lost. This may include condominium bylaws, contracts, or invoices/receipts from services. In some instances, these documents may include a limitation or complete bar on subrogation claims. A necessary document may also include a subrogation waiver, if required by the insured’s policy. At the beginning of claim handling, it is important to obtain a subrogation waiver from your insured. Some policies contain language whereby the assignment occurs automatically after any payment is made. Other policies require an additional step from the insured to affirmatively assign their rights to the carrier. Despite the insured having a legal obligation to provide the assignment if requested, it may take weeks or months to contact an insured, which may result in the statute of limitations running.
Just as important as gathering all ingredients, you want to avoid overbaking a cake. No one wants a burnt cake, right? Similarly, we don’t want to sit on a claim too long before gathering the evidence, providing notice to adverse parties, getting an exam performed, and retaining an attorney. The longer you wait to examine the evidence, the more likely it will be lost or tampered with, resulting in the integrity of your claim being compromised. Additionally, when it comes to negotiations, attorney involvement can place pressure on an adverse party and ensure a timely settlement. If we overbake a claim and do not involve an attorney within a reasonable time before the statute of limitations runs, the ability to negotiate may be negatively affected.
Like overbaking a cake, underbaking can be equally detrimental. So, when is the right time to send a pre-suit demand? It is never too early to serve a contractor with notice of a potential claim. Chapter 558 of the Florida Statutes provides a notice requirement for all construction defect cases. You must provide a contractor with notice via certified mail and an opportunity to inspect and fix the alleged defect. Failure to do so may be detrimental to your case. As to other claims, presenting a claim to an adverse party without proof of payments, invoices, pictures, and potentially expert reports will result in an early denial that may be difficult to have reconsidered.
If your claim is denied and the question is whether to close it out, file arbitration, or file suit, ask yourself if placing this case into trial is worth the risk of not settling with the offer on the table. You may have a family recipe for brownies and come across a new recipe that is fudgier and more chocolatey than your family recipe. Know when to toss that old recipe and replace it. Don’t become so attached that you sacrifice your great baker reputation! Some claims are better than others, if the facts and evidence aren’t there, it may be time to close it out and move on to better and tastier things.
May 22, 2023
Achieving success in the subrogation field is largely dependent on the team of subrogation professionals and/or attorneys that you assemble. The two simple, yet critical elements to building your subrogation dream team are hiring the right people for the job and raising them to be stars of your team. Every employer has different criteria that they use to help determine the best employee to hire. Most will focus on pedigree and experience in the subrogation field. Employers feel more comfortable hiring an employee who has previously worked in subrogation as they feel they will most likely be easier to train and start producing results sooner. However, if you hire the right kind of employee and have an established training program for your subrogation team, prior subrogation experience is not necessarily a requirement.
The three essential traits of a great subrogation hire are someone who is trainable, has a compatible personality, and is a team player. Determining if a potential hire is trainable is key to their long-term success on your team. Whether it’s a 20-year seasoned veteran of the subrogation industry or a green adjuster/attorney that has no clue as to what subrogation means (outside of their quick Google search of the term in preparation for their interview), finding someone who has the willingness to learn is highly important. Teaching a new subrogation hire takes time and requires the new employee to have the patience to start from the basics and gradually learn the process. If the new hire is unwilling to learn your group’s subrogation process and listen to constructive criticism of their supervisors, then this can
substantially hurt the chances of the employee becoming an effective member of the team.
Hiring an employee with a compatible personality is one of the most important attributes but is probably the most difficult to attain. Your current team’s culture will determine which type of personality you are looking for. You want a new team member that will fit in with your current group and bring something new to the table. For example, our subrogation group at DSBC consists of a diverse set of personalities and people but the common theme is being a “good” person and team player. We spend so much time with our work family that you want to enjoy who you are spending your time with. This starts with people who prioritize respect. All members of the team are required to treat each other with respect. Whether senior management or a new intern, all teammates must respect one another. Here at DSBC, we also adhere to the work hard/play hard mentality. Hitting your recovery goals takes an immense amount of grinding and effort throughout the year. However, there is no reason why your team cannot have fun while working through the grind. Find team members that have enthusiasm, charisma, and are enjoyable to work with. If your new employee’s personality fits in with your team, then you are more likely to avoid unnecessary office drama and they will improve your team’s work environment.
The last essential trait for a new member of the team is being a team player. Hitting your subrogation recovery goals takes a village. Every member of your team needs to be invested in helping, however possible, to achieve your goals. Whenever an issue/challenge arises, all team members need to be ready and willing to assist. If team members are solely focused on their own recovery numbers, then it can hurt your team’s morale and your ability to achieve the group’s recovery goal. Being a good team player also involves checking your ego at the door and being willing to assist in any task whether it’s big or small. When selecting your new employee, focus on whether they are going to be a willing helper regardless of the task.
The last step to building your subrogation dream team is building an established training system to put your new hires in the best position to succeed. First and foremost, having supervisors and senior members of the group spend time with the new employees is essential to your training system. Your senior members of the team are your best assets in training your new teammates. This obviously requires your senior members to be willing to commit some of their work time to training but the eventual rewards are more than worth it. One of the best tools for training is observation. Trainees learn best when they can observe other members of the team while they are handling their daily duties. Whether its new attorneys shadowing senior attorneys in depositions, mediations, and hearings or subrogation professionals bringing new hires onto their phone calls to observe, this type of experience is essential in training your new employee and also showing them the culture of your group. Another key training tool is making all members of your team accessible to the new employees for questions. The different members of the team can pass on different lessons and strategies to help the new teammate build their own work routine. Making sure that you have an open-door policy for the new employees is extremely helpful in ensuring they feel comfortable enough to ask questions. Lastly, empowering your new employees is key to them becoming self-sufficient and effective members of your team. Constructive criticism is part of any good training system but building up your new employee’s confidence is important as well. When mistakes are made by a new employee, it is important to focus on finding a solution and using the experience as a teachable moment for them. When new team members accomplish tasks, make sure the senior members of the team take time to show praise as well. Instilling confidence in your new employees will help produce more competent and self-sufficient members of your team.
Building your dream subrogation team is a combination of finding the right teammates and providing them the proper training to succeed. While prior experience in the subrogation field is certainly helpful, it does not need to be a prerequisite to hiring a new member of your subrogation team. As long as you prioritize the compatible personality traits that fit your group in the hiring process and develop an effective training system, you can continue to grow and strengthen your subrogation team.
May 8, 2023
Succeeding on a common law indemnity claim can prove to be difficult, if not impossible, for a general contractor seeking indemnification from a subcontractor. DSBC Partner Hillarie Miller discusses the limits of indemnification in construction contracts.
April 24, 2023
Motions for Summary Judgment are a useful tool for insurance companies to have a Court rule on issues in a case as a matter of law before those issues are presented to a jury. DSBC Associate Marni Rogalsky breaks down its use in the context of defending first-party property cases.
April 13, 2023
Many legal practitioners are familiar with the doctrine of subrogation while some may only recall from their Bar studies. You are invited to walk this article’s literary path, which traverses a lesser-known avenue of subrogation by way of Additional Personal Injury Protection (“APIP”) coverage.
March 16, 2023
Senior Associate Michelle Smith Lambert explores the implications of Senate Bill 2A on Florida Statute § 627.428.
March 6, 2023
Senior Associate Mary Grecz explains the Sutton Doctrine and how it affects subrogation.
January 23, 2023
Subrogation is the right of an insurance company to be repaid the money they spent on an injured policyholder while their personal injury claim was pending. Find out how to proceed when your subrogation target passes away.